Ethical manager vs Effective manager

Ethics vs Effectiveness :-

The clash between effectiveness and ethics is something that managers face almost regularly. Sometimes, choosing to be ethical can seem redundant, yielding no fruit. A compromise with ethics can lead to earlier completion of the goal and thereby, higher effectiveness.

But this effectiveness achieved by compromising with ethics needs to be looked at with greater scrutiny. Whenever a compromise with ethics is made, a trade-off occurs. A trade-off between trust & effectiveness. The increased effectiveness comes at a prize of diminishing trust amongst the subordinates. The team loses its trust in their manager as well. The process is gradual and not evident. This, in turn, compromises the cohesion of the group. In the long run, due to this lack in cohesion, the effectiveness is greatly decreased.

This brings us to the question that whether the initial surge in effectiveness could even be classified as effectiveness at all? Keeping the bigger picture in mind, the answer is most certainly no. True effectiveness can only be achieved when morals and ethics form the foundation of the team. They build mutual trust, belief, and reliance between the team members and the manager which is essential for the cohesion of the group. And cohesion is the key to higher effectiveness in the long run.

In conclusion, following the path of morals and ethics may not yield dividends in the shorter run. But they will definitely be fruitful in the longer run. Ethics lead to effectiveness.

Your Turn…

What are your thoughts on this topic? Tell us through the comment section below. And subscribe to our blog to read answers to trending GD topics.


Copyright @ Group Discussion Ideas.

You may also like : All GD topics with Answers

Subscribe to GD Ideas

1 comment

  1. According to me Manager means who manages everything . Ethics is very important in our life . But in the team when people work in the field they face some practical problems and manager has to take care of it . May be sometimes ethically it will not be able to solved then manager has to solve it in a diplomatic way. First of all team members has to get rid of the problem but obviously in a honest way. Always ethics does not work . So Effective manager is better than ethical manager.

Join in the Group Discussion...

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *