Abrogation of Article 370

abrogation of article 370

Theme:-

  • On 7th August 2019, President Ram Nath Kovind declared abrogation of Article 370 of the Indian constitution after the resolution to revoke the article was passed by both the houses of the parliament (Rajya Sabha & Lok Sabha).

What is article 370?

  • Article 370 is a temporary provision of the Indian constitution which grants special status to the state of Jammu & Kashmir, under part XXI of the Constitution of India which deals with ‘Temporary, Transitional and Special Provisions’. Article 370 is the only constitutional link between India and Jammu & Kashmir.

Some major provisions of Article 370:- 

  • According to this article, except for foreign affairs, defence, finance and communication, Indian Parliament needs the approval of State Legislature for applying all other laws.
  • The Union government cannot declare emergency in Jammu & Kashmir unless there is a case of war or external aggression. In case of any internal disturbance or imminent danger, an emergency can be applied only by the request of state government or by its approval.
  • Citizens of J & K follow their own constitution and Indians of other states cannot buy property in J&K.
  • In India, the residuary powers are vested with the Union Government but in case of Jammu & Kashmir, the residuary powers are vested with the state government.

Benefits of removing Article 370:-

  • As per Article 370, people of other regions cannot buy land or settle in Jammu & Kashmir. This is acting against the development of the region. By abolishing article 370, teachers, doctors and other professionals can settle there bringing better facilities. And also industries can be set up in the region and hence Jammu & Kashmir can be economically developed.
  • By abolishing this article, the government can act tough against the terrorism present in the region.
  • Many laws such as The prohibition of Child Marriage Act, women’s reservation were not applicable to Jammu & Kashmir, because of the provisions of Article 370. Now, all laws of India will be applicable to J&K also.

Disadvantages of removing Article 370:-

  • Citizens of Jammu & Kashmir are facing so much struggle because of many reasons such as the fight between India and Pakistan, the constant presence of troops, unemployment crisis etc. So if the special status is also removed, they may feel like their voice is suppressed.
  • People of J&K have a feeling that settlers from other regions will change the demography of the region. So, due to the abolition of article 370, they may protest against the central government.

Timeline:-

  • With 1954 Presidential Orders almost the entire constitution was extended to Jammu & Kashmir including most of the Constitutional Amendments.
  • Nehru said in Lok Sabha in 1963 that Article 370 has eroded.
  • 94 of 97 entries in the Union List are applicable to J&K; 26 out of 47 entries of the Concurrent List have been extended. 260 of 395 Articles have been extended to the state, besides 7 of 12 Schedules.
  • There is a provision in Article 370 that it can only be revoked by the consultation of the constituent assembly of Jammu & Kashmir, but the constituent assembly dissolved itself in 1957. And since then it has been a major issue in revoking Article 370.

Conclusion:-

Repealing Article 370 to develop the region is a good and bold step by the government. This step will help in integrating the Jammu & Kashmir region with the rest of India. But the way it was done is against the democratic principles because the public or the state leaders are not consulted before passing this bill. To prevent the negative consequences, the government should take effective steps for the development of the region on a war footing. There is a need to improve employment opportunities as promised. It is the responsibility of the government to make the people of Jammu & Kashmir feel safe and secured.

Your Turn…

What is your opinion on this topic? Do you support revoking Article 370? Express your thoughts in the comment section below. And subscribe to our blog to read answers to trending GD topics.


Copyright @ Group Discussion Ideas.

Subscribe to GD Ideas

Please subscribe to our YouTube channel. You will get good content & we will get a subscriber. It’s a win-win for both of us. 😃

19 comments

  1. friends in my words revoke of article 370 is the great decision took by government and it is a every Indian dream. abolish of article 370 helpful for jammu and kashmir. mainly tourism will be develops. education system also developed. the main reason for revoked article 370 for defeat of terrorism. investors are from other countries and our countries come forward to put invest on industries and to create employment to youth of jammu and kashmir who are in the unemployment status. rather it economically developed.

  2. Friends acc to me it was really a very bold decision taken by modi govt bcoz no other govt can think about abrogation of article 370 . By this j and k people have equal access to job. The region will face development as earlier the development was not possible in mass level due to barrier of Constitution. And most important thing we can say that now police force is under the control of Central govt., earlier some police personnel were supporting the stone pelters as they create conflicts or problems against the encounter of terrorists. But now from this provision police can take strict steps to eradicate this stone pelting. Youngsters should go to their studies rather than to throw stones on jawans .it creates bad reputation of our country in world and abrogation of article 370 will surely remove this.
    Thanks
    This is my first attempt . So if I have made any err regarding this plj reply me. It will help me a lot

    1. sahil you had done group discussion well in this topic. what was you told is absolutely correct. i like you for you used one word “pelting ” was good. keep going
      thank you

  3. Yes I agree with the decision taken by the government about abolishing the Article 370 as it will help the jammu and Kashmir region to develop.

  4. Yes I definitely support abolish ment of article 370 .It will help government to work for Kashmir.

  5. After abolition of article 370 India had faced many changes like increase ing employment, foreigners tourist, and in industrial area had also help to devloping in economics system. That’s according to me it’s is beneficial for our country

  6. Abrogation of Article 370 is decisive step towards advancement of Jammu & Kashmir.
    It will positively affect the J&K’s life through following ways:
    1.Declaring Ladakh as a separate UT ,will improve the governance and administration in the isolated region.
    2.It now allows foreign investors to set up infrastructure, invest in businesses, which will subsequently increase employment opportunities.
    3.Government now possesses the rights to enforce civil laws in J&K, for the welfare of citizens.
    4.Terrorism can be dealt with, more effectively now.
    The revoking of Article 370 is completely in the favor of the state,and will work to boost the economy.

  7. In my view, it is a good decision. By removal of article 370,rules is same for everyone from kashmir to kanyakumari.Terrorists enter into our country through kashmir and they are killing our soldiers and bomb blasts in our country,because it is under state government.By removal of article of 370,it comes under union Government. Any person can buy properties in jammu&kashmir and due to this it will be developed economically. For safety of jammu &kashmir increases more soldiers in that specific areas where terrosists attack took place.

  8. In my point of view it is a great step. Investors from other states and countries will be attracted. Investment will create huge employment opportunities for the people of J & K. Highly reputed education intitutes will be established in J & K thereby providing opportunities to students and they need not go out of state for education.

  9. In my perception, abrogation of Article 370 is a bold step taken by Indian government, and I would like congratulate our nation’s government for this. This will bring strong economy and better opportunities for the citizens of Jammu and Kashmir. Moreover it is welcomed by the citizens of Jammu and Kashmir with the open hands. This step unites India in the first place and will give more power to people of Jammu and Kashmir to enjoy their rights. Along with this, declared Laddak as a separate Union territory is one of the best decision taken by Indian government, thus the citizens of Laddak are now able to enjoy their rights and will have better opportunities of employment, education etc. Abrogation of Article 370 is good for the nation and the dream of every India is now fulfil that we have one nation one constitution.

  10. I think abrogation of article 370 is a good decision by govt. as it helps in development of the region and bring equality among people. it also help in to fight against terrorism in the region.

  11. According to me revoked article 370 it’s a strong decision. After independence no other government had courage to take this bold decision because of vote bank. Modi government got the opportunity because of they have parliament and Rajyjo Sabha has full majority. Actually Article 370 is the tool of terrorism and Pakistan used to take the advantage. But now article 370 abolished so any people can go there for work purpose and settle there . If industry will set up then common people will get the job , unemployment problem will solve. If people will get the job they will be busy and they will not get time to involve in bad activities. They will get all civic amenities like water , electricity, health system and education like other state. We everybody aware Kashmir is the paradise , if more and more people will go there for visiting purpose then Kashmir tourism industry will develop. Now people have desire to go but they get afraid if normalcy will come then people don’t need to think. So state economy will develop. According to me it is not like that all the people involved in bad activities so common, innocent people may be they are very happy to abolish this article 370.

  12. I think its a good step taken by government because when people from other states start settling in J&K , they may have positive effect on the citizens of J&K by interacting with them. Thus J&K citizens feel more secured and united and this contribute to one nation one constitution.

  13. In my point of view, the article 370 should not be removed instantly from our constitution. As it got nullified to a large extent, government should focus on subjects which can provide all round development in a state rather revoking instantly. If state government collectively work with central government to resolve issues in a state then lots of problems will settle down. Non residents along with minorities of the state are not allowed to get amenities provided by government also they do not have voting rights which is not according to the democracy and this thing has to be nullified. Likewise, looking into one another issues article 370 can be nullify. After implementation of the new subjects and after getting confidence of citizens, finally it can removed peacefully.

      1. According to my perception that is a best decision taken by the Indian government because the people of Kashmir find a good investment from all over the country which means they have a lot of the employment due to the lack of the employment these people take part in a stone pelting but 370 revoked which means these as people has a lot of the employment and these people peacefully follow the path of peace that is good for our country

Join in the Group Discussion...

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *